Posted on: Thursday, July 16th, 2009
The other day I mentioned on Twitter that I was interested in checking out some Wreckhouse International Jazz and Blues Festival. Very quickly I had a few friends message me and recommend checking out The Bad Plus. So I did.
First of all, allow me to preface by saying my jazz knowledge is limited to Richard Cheese, so don’t expect me to be incredibly technical.

The Bad Plus is a unique band, head to toe. Different sound, different style, and a curiously distinct sense of rocking out. They have no trouble jamming until their fingers bleed or capturing the audience’s attention with a stunned silence. When they hit a good rhythm they rock it suberbly and it is not a performance I will soon forget. But I have to say I walked away from this show with a mixed opinion.
I hate keeping my thumbs from the up or down position entirely, but believe me when I say when they were amazing when they hit a good song, like David King’s Anthem of the Ernest (off the “Suspicious Activity?” album), but mostly incoherent and confusing when they played pieces like Mint by Ethan Iverson (off the “Prog” album). I couldn’t wait for that song to finish. It was very difficult to understand.

Don’t read into Prog the wrong way though. Reid Anderson’s song Giant, also performed last night, was from that album and another one of their amazing tunes.
The problem with some of their music was that if they didn’t tell you song names you would assume they were a high school band class, each instrument trying to outperform the other rather than working together. Those few songs were an improvizational mess. This problem made much of their music confusing.

But I can’t hang them out to dry, they were redeemed with popular covers like the “electronic masters” Aphex Twin or Rush’s Tom Sawyer, except jazzified.
For the spectator who would get bored watching three stationary instruments for a full show there is the drummer, David King, whose drumrolling theatrics is enough to entertain for a show of its own.

As a band that came highly recommended, I’m disappointed. As a band I knew nothing about, I’m impressed. These guys tour the world so they are doing something right, I just can’t quite figure out what it is.
Photos by Phil Hann